Islamorada punches well above its weight when it comes to food. Between fresh-caught seafood, waterfront views, and laid-back Keys vibes, you'll eat well here. Here are the best spots — starting with our own.
Hungry Tarpon Restaurant
Waterfront Seafood & BarOur own waterfront restaurant — fresh seafood, the famous Trailer Trash Bloody Mary, and the best seats in the house watching the tarpon feed below.
View Menu →Morada Bay Beach Cafe
Beach Bar & GrillFull moon parties, tiki torches, feet-in-the-sand dining on the bayside. A true Keys classic.
Chef Michael's
Fine DiningThe upscale option in Islamorada — chef-driven menu, local seafood elevated to its fullest.
Lorelei Restaurant & Cabana Bar
Waterfront BarCasual bayside dining with stunning sunset views. Great for drinks after a day on the water.
Ziggie & Mad Dog's
Casual DiningA local favorite — laid-back atmosphere, solid food, and a good draft beer selection.
Square Grouper
SeafoodFresh local catch, friendly service, reliably good food. A must-stop on the Overseas Highway.
Islamorada Shrimp Shack
Casual SeafoodAffordable, fresh, and very local. Shrimp platters and Keys-style sides done right.
Mangrove Mike's Cafe
Breakfast & LunchThe spot for a hearty Keys breakfast before a day of fishing or snorkeling.
Italian Food Company
ItalianGreat pizza and pasta in an unexpected Keys setting — popular with locals.
